Of the listed groups, what I said in the poll stands, but overall? Anyone who didn't ship that particular pair, or the Girl Cooties Brigade.
Given the narrative restrictions placed on what they could do, and RTD's notorious reluctance for putting a firm 'CASE CLOSED' stamp on any of the long-term companions, this is kinda what some of us had been figuring might become the 'happy' ending even just after LotTL.
There's definitely some better ways the could have handled it (particularly Donna's ending: couldn't they have just had him pull out the relevant section and said the energies involved in TARDIS travel would've reawakened the Time Lordiness and therefore she couldn't travel with him any more, but she still had her memories?), but the other likely alternative would've been coming back at Christmas to Ten laying flowers at Rose's grave and then returning from the PW to N-Space.
no subject
Date: 2008-07-10 07:30 pm (UTC)Given the narrative restrictions placed on what they could do, and RTD's notorious reluctance for putting a firm 'CASE CLOSED' stamp on any of the long-term companions, this is kinda what some of us had been figuring might become the 'happy' ending even just after LotTL.
There's definitely some better ways the could have handled it (particularly Donna's ending: couldn't they have just had him pull out the relevant section and said the energies involved in TARDIS travel would've reawakened the Time Lordiness and therefore she couldn't travel with him any more, but she still had her memories?), but the other likely alternative would've been coming back at Christmas to Ten laying flowers at Rose's grave and then returning from the PW to N-Space.